It’s not uncommon for seal manufacturers to test their materials in various fluids to better understand their compatibility. Most tests run from a week to about a month. They’re performed in heated fluids to simulate hydraulic applications and determine if the materials will maintain their intended properties over time. But System Seals wondered what would happen if the tests ran longer – much longer. Would they find different results? It turns out, they did.
The difference in nearly half these tests, however, was the duration. System Seals ran the simulations from 60 to 90 days, and in some cases even longer. The results were astonishing. More than 25 percent of the material-fluid combinations that safely passed the 28-day mark began to fail near or after 60 days. This meant that a quarter of all tests that are commonly performed throughout the industry are showing false results.
All of the materials underwent stringent testing, included breaking points, tensile strength, elongation, volume swell, abrasion resistance and hardness – all qualities required for safe seal performance and longevity. Several of the fluid-material combinations that passed successfully within 28 days and then failed afterwards are widely regarded throughout the industry as acceptable.
“One critical point we discovered was that certain materials, such as HNBR, often have many different variations, and the variants don’t all behave the same way,” said Kurt Sassmannshausen, product development manager with System Seals. “Some materials perform quite well, but because of the varying levels of ACN, fillers and degree of saturation, others in the same family start to degrade after just a couple of months.”
The research not only debunked some commonly held beliefs about fluid-material combinations, it also proved that entire material categories can no longer be grouped as one. Specific material blends must be detailed by the OEMs with recommended fluids.
Fluid compatibility is a major cause of early degradation and seal failure. This was one of several major studies performed by System Seals, which recently introduced its new Cylinder Optimization Program – a systematic process that analyses a cylinder’s properties well beyond what is commonly known by the OEMs or end users.
For more information, contact a System Seals industry expert at www.systemseals.com or call (216) 220-1800.
Our customers work directly with industry specialists and application engineers who ensure the best solution for each application. Contact one of our specialists now to discuss how we can help solve your stubborn problems and substantially increase equipment performance.Choose a Specialist